Zillow Sues IPO-Seeking Rival Trulia Over Home-Estimate Patent
Specifically, Zillow (NASDAQ: Z) says Trulia is copying its patented system of letting web users add information to automatic property value estimates—a feature that Zillow has offered since 2006, and that Trulia added last year.
Just last week, Seattle-based Zillow raised about $147 million in a secondary sale of stock, a move that harvested some of the public-market hunger for online real estate stocks as Trulia waits on deck. That stock sale brought Zillow nearly double the cash raised through Zillow’s own $75 million IPO last year.
In the federal lawsuit, filed Wednesday in Seattle, Zillow is seeking unspecified damages that could include patent licensing fees. In its court filing, Zillow calls Trulia’s home estimate feature a “blatant and ongoing copying of Zillow’s innovative approach to home valuation.”
A Trulia spokesman declined to comment on the lawsuit to the Puget Sound Business Journal. (The PSBJ also has a copy of Zillow’s complaint posted online, for anyone who wants to read the actual paperwork.)
Zillow calls its home-value estimates “Zestimates,” and they’ve been both a marketing tool and a source of contention from homeowners and real estate agents from the beginning.
One way that Zillow seeks to calm people who don’t agree with the algorithm that determines their home value is to let them log in and add more information to the property’s profile, in an attempt to make the estimate more accurate. Zillow says about a third of the 100 million-plus property estimates in its system have had information added this way.
In its lawsuit, Zillow says it applied for a patent on the user-information feature in 2006, and was awarded a patent in June 2011. Trulia rolled out its own home estimating feature, which also included user input, in September 2011.
Unless they didn’t have lawyers on the case, you can assume that Trulia probably knew about its competitor’s patents when it was developing the estimates. Zillow isn’t specifically called out in the discussion of risks in Trulia’s IPO paperwork, but the company does offer the usual warning about the possibility of intellectual property lawsuits.
Zillow has been a point of pride for the Seattle-area technology industry, which had seen a long drought for homegrown IPOs before Zillow hit the markets last year. The company has performed well since going public, which must be a relief for investors and employees who endured the worst housing crash in generations.
But many in the tech industry also have strongly negative opinions on patents relating to software and relatively simple features, such as allowing users to add information to an algorithm. It’ll be interesting to see if Zillow’s moves against Trulia are received as a sharp-elbowed competitive strategy to defend its market, or as a less-than-honorable dig at a rival.