Hitting the Target, Missing the Mark: How Targeted Therapies Have Left Patients Wanting

Opinion

(Page 2 of 2)

has been recognized as a key component of the disease. The complex interplay of these factors makes it difficult to use a therapy that targets one specific intermediate in one specific pathway and expect it to have disease-modifying effects at acceptable dosing levels.

3. Hitting multifunctional targets can cause unwanted effects.

Many proteins consist of different subunits or exist in multiple isoforms. Different subunit and isoform combinations can be involved in a variety of tissue- and cell type-specific processes. Inhibition of the semagacestat target outside of the brain, for example, has been associated with an increased frequency of cancer and alterations of the gastrointestinal lining. Using a single-target approach to affect multi-functional proteins can result in outcomes that differ significantly from the anticipated effect.

These difficulties are not unique to Alzheimer’s disease. New therapies for multiple sclerosis using similar targeted approaches have received “black box” warnings while still in clinical development. The complexity of disease mechanisms creates many challenges in choosing a specific “drugable” target and, once a target is chosen, often requires large doses to demonstrate efficacy.

New approaches for treating chronic disease should be explored. The current view of a cell as a collection of distinct and separate targets responsible for individual biochemical reactions presents substantial challenges for drug development. Approaching the cell as a whole may better reflect the way the human body functions and may have a higher likelihood of yielding new therapeutics.

Developing therapeutics that do not compromise “normal” cellular functions could also minimize side effects. Targeting the activation of specific immune cell populations could allow broad therapeutic action by dampening an exaggerated inflammatory reaction without crippling the entire immune response. In chronic inflammatory diseases, T and B cells, along with antigen-presenting cells, present an opportunity to block the amplification of the immune response that ultimately is responsible for the damage caused by the disease. Recent work examining a protective effect of regulatory T cells in Parkinson’s disease has given credence to this approach.

The challenges of developing novel therapeutics remain daunting. New approaches to chronic disease processes are needed to provide a more comprehensive solution to complex disease mechanisms while maintaining low side effect profiles. The current paradigm for the isolation of specific targets may not be sufficient to accomplish this goal. New classes of therapeutics will be required to address these issues. Success in this challenging endeavor will ultimately benefit patients.

Single PageCurrently on Page: 1 2 previous page

Richard Watson is the director of clinical research at Tacoma, WA-based Revalesio. Follow @

Trending on Xconomy