Hydrogen Cars: Saving the Environment’s a Gas

6/2/09

Cruising north on Interstate-5 in a Chevy Equinox hardly sounds like a reason to be excited, but I felt lighter than air yesterday. That may just be an effect of the hydrogen fueling the car, or perhaps just the giddy sensation that comes from driving the future of General Motors on the same day their future looks so uncertain. Whatever the cause, my heart was beating loudly as I drove the 40 miles or so from Ft. Lewis to Seattle in a caravan of other hydrogen fuel cell cars. My heart was definitely much louder than the practically inaudible sound of the fuel stack converting hydrogen to electricity and water.

The Equinox is a compact sport utility vehicle, sort of like a minivan for people who don’t want to drive minivans. This Equinox is one of eight hydrogen powered cars from Daimler, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai-Kia, Nissan, Toyota and Volkswagen traveling north from Chula Vista, CA to Vancouver, BC as part of the second annual Hydrogen Road tour. The cars, which left on May 26 and will finish their tour on June 3, are stopping at 28 cities along the way to give people a chance to try out the cars and learn about hydrogen fuel cells. To put it simply, hydrogen fuel cells work like batteries, with the hydrogen ionizing into electrons and protons. The electrons are forced through a circuit, creating an electric current. The waste products coming out the end of the tailpipe are just water and a little bit of heat—much cleaner than internal combustion exhaust.Hydrogen Engine

One cell produces very little voltage, but stacked together they do quite well. The Equinox I drove could produce 94 kW, reach highway speeds of as much as 100 miles an hour (electronically regulated to prevent overtaxing the fuel cells), and go 150 miles on just 4.2 kilograms of compressed hydrogen.

I got the experience of what it’s like to drive one of these cars this morning, when I drove down to Fort Lewis near Tacoma, WA. Fort Lewis was chosen as one of the sites to stop at because the military is building a hydrogen fuel maker from a wastewater treatment plant and plans to have a shuttle bus and 19 forklifts that run on hydrogen gas sometime in the next couple of years.

Fort Lewis also currently is expanding its use of other alternate fuels such as biodiesel and ethanol. “We’re trying everything to see what’s best,” says Miriam Easley, sustainability outreach coordinator at Fort Lewis. With the military rather than civilians in charge, much can get done quickly, including testing different alternative fuels in a semi-closed economy. “If anybody can get it right, the military can get it right,” said Col. Cynthia Murphy, garrison commander at Fort Lewis.

Much of the future of alternate fuel vehicles depends on the infrastructure available to support them. If there were enough places for people to fuel hydrogen powered cars, people would be more willing to buy them. But to create demand for the fueling stations, the cars have to be already sold. “It’s a chicken and egg question,” said Dawn McKenzie, and assistant manager of product communications for GM and one of my passengers as I drove. This is a thorny problem for car manufacturers. Washington does not currently have any hydrogen stations, but it does offer other types of alternative fuel. After driving back to Seattle, we went to one of them, a Propel station providing both ethanol and biodiesel.Hydrogen Cars

Compared to hybrid vehicles like the Prius this felt more like a gasoline powered car, albeit quieter. There’s no abrupt transition like in the Prius between the battery and gasoline engine. If it weren’t for a small indicator light, it would be hard to tell if the car was even on.

Perhaps the most important and most subtle aspect of driving a hydrogen car is that it really is not that different in feeling from driving a regular car. But it is quieter, more economical and decidedly more environmentally-friendly than standard gasoline engines. It’s easy to imagine a transition in America to these kinds of cars. It’s a hope that keeps me buoyant.

Eric Hal Schwartz was an intern in Xconomy's Seattle office. Follow @

By posting a comment, you agree to our terms and conditions.

  • Pingback: Hydrogen Cars: Saving the Environment’s a Gas - Xconomy | The Green Outlet Store

  • http://www.theenergyroadmap.com Garry

    Glad you enjoyed the ride! I would just add that for automakers the incentive for fuel cells integrated with batteries and capacitors for electric power trains – is a lower cost manufacturing platform. So the revolution is reducing the industry’s Manufacturing Footprint, not Carbon Footprint. Moving beyond the combustion engine allows companies to reduce their supply chains and number of factories– around more scalable and modular energy storage and conversion systems.

    So this is a plus for the environment and economy — and add some digital software to this electric platform and suddently we can imagine sales around software enhanced driving experiences!

    So — while batteries are likely to be first– hydrogen fuel cells are going to play a major role in next generation electric vehicles.

    Thanks for sharing your experience!
    Garry G
    Editor
    The Energy Roadmap

  • Reader

    I think you need to look deeper than their greenwashed road tour. Hydrogen automobiles are a boondoggle that the auto and oil industry has been pushing for several decades now, because hydrogen provides a way to maintain control that BEV (battery electric) vehicles do not. Where the control is most important for the auto companies and Big Oil is control of the fuel supply and continued dealer maintenance revenue.

    The problems with the “hydrogen hype” are numerous. There is no hydrogen fuelling infrastructure, and building one is not economically feasible. The prototype cars you drove typically cost around a million dollars to build, because they rely on expensive platinum catalysts. Improvements in fuel cells have been slow in coming.

    Compare that to a BEV like the Tesla which is available now, you can refuel it yourself at home and it requires very little maintenance.

    And what was the source of the hydrogen that powered those vehicles? There are no “hydrogen wells”. The source of most commercial hydrogen is fossil fuels, so it doesn’t help with our addiction to foreign oil or global climate change.

    More info at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hype_about_Hydrogen

  • http://www.biodiversivist.com Russ Finley

    The following diagram tries to explain why hydrogen will never be used for car transport:

    http://home.comcast.net/~russ676/Graphics/img23.gif

    In addition, the hydrogen was made out of fossil fuels. The pollution emitted was all upstream.