Steel in Their Eyes—Why VCs should be Startup CEOs
(Page 2 of 2)
having some junior employee tell me why they couldn’t do something because of “how hard it was” didn’t get much sympathy from me. I knew how hard it was because I had done it myself. Startups are hard.
What running a company would do is give early-stage VC’s a benchmark for reality, something most newly-minted partners sorely lack. They would learn how a founding CEO turns their money into a company which becomes a learning, execution, and delivery engine. They would learn that a CEO does it through the people—the day-to-day of who is going to do what, how you hold people accountable, how teams communicate, and more importantly, who you hire, how you motivate and get people to accomplish the seemingly impossible. Further, they’d experience first hand how, in a startup, the devil is in the details of execution and deliverables.
My hypotheses is simple: what most VCs lack is not brains or rolodex or people skill, but hands-on experience as startup CEOs—knowing what it’s like trying to make a payroll while finding sufficient customers while you’re building the product. Sure, a year as a CEO won’t make them an expert, but it will change them quicker than 10 years in the boardroom.
Does it Matter?
There’s a school of thought that says the skill set of a great early-stage VC —awesome people skills, curiosity, likable, etc,— versus the attributes of a great entrepreneur—pattern recognition, tenacity, etc.—may not have much overlap. Early stage investing is not a spreadsheet, quantitatively driven exercise, nor is it about technology—it is a deal business and people drive the deals. And while having experience as a startup CEO may make you a better board member, it may not substantively contribute to your career as an early stage investor—which depend on many more important skills.
Steel in their Eyes
Ten years ago starting a company required millions of dollars and first customer ship took years. Now it’s possible to build a company, ship product and get tens of thousands of customers in a year with less than $500K. For venture firms who want to groom/grow associates or operating execs into partners (rather than hiring proven partners), here’s my suggestion:
- Have them start as an analyst (search for deal flow and people, due diligence)
- Then take a year as a product manager in a startup in the firm’s portfolio
- Then come back as an associate for a year—shadowing board and partner meetings
- Then take a year and $250-500K to start and run a mobile/Web/cloud company. See what it’s really like on the other side of that boardroom table
- Then return as a partner.
This process will create a new generation of venture capital partners, ones who have been battle tested in the trenches of a startup, hardened by hiring and firing, tempered by making a payroll and losing orders. They will never forget it’s all about the people.
These VCs would return to their firms with steel in their eyes. They’d be relentless about accountability from board meeting to board meeting with laser like focus on the one or two issues that matter. They would understand the CEO-VC-board dynamic in a way that few who hadn’t lived it could. They’d be ruthless in their choice of people and teams, looking for those few who have natural curiosity, a passion to win, and who won’t take no for answer.
- Venture capital is still a “craft business”
- Early stage VCs should have startup CEO experience
- It can now be gained cheaply and quickly
- It will give them perspective and edge that would take a decade to learn.