San Diego’s Homegrown VCs Waning, But Out-of-Town VCs Make Up the Difference
Here’s a question that CEOs might be able to relate to: What should you do when the purring financial machinery under your control just doesn’t feel right (and the anecdotal evidence suggests something has gone haywire) but your outside auditor is saying, “Nope. Everything is looking pretty normal to me.”
In this particular case, the purring financial machinery is San Diego’s venture capital community and the auditor is Bill Molloie, a venture industry veteran and the new head of PricewaterhouseCoopers’ emerging life sciences practice in San Diego. Before landing in San Diego earlier this year, Molloie spent three years in China, where he led PwC’s venture practice in Shanghai.
When I met Molloie for lunch a few weeks ago, along with PwC’s Brian Caisman, we talked at length about the unusually weak showing in first-quarter venture capital investments for the San Diego region. A survey done by PwC, the National Venture Capital Association, and Thomson Reuters counted just $87 million invested in 15 local deals. The amount invested was down 57 percent from the previous quarter and 80 percent from the first quarter of 2008.
The data reflects the effects of the worst recession in decades, of course. But beyond that, I told Molloie it appears that several of San Diego’s homegrown venture capital firms no longer appear to be actively investing—although the principals would never publicly acknowledge it.
I showed Molloie some VC industry data I had collected from the National Venture Capital Association. The Virginia-based NVCA found that in 2008 there were 17 venture capital firms with headquarters in San Diego, an increase from 10 homegrown VCs in San Diego that the NVCA counted a decade earlier. But I’m skeptical of the data. Several of the VCs on the 2008 list might still be paying their NVCA membership dues, but they have not been investing. What may be more relevant is a list from the NVCA that shows just seven San Diego-based VCs have raised new funds since 2005: Avalon Ventures, BSD Venture Capital, Finistere Partners, Mesa Verde Venture Partners, Mission Ventures, Revolution Ventures, and TVC Capital.
I also showed Molloie data from Dow Jones Venture Source that shows VCs headquartered in San Diego were involved in just 8 percent—13 of 158—of the venture-backed deals that were counted in the region last year. That’s almost half the number in 2003, when San Diego-based VCs were involved in 15 percent (27 of 177) of the venture deals in the local region.
After absorbing all this, Molloie promised to do his own analysis of San Diego’s venture data. His conclusion: “There are not a lot of funds that have dropped out,” perhaps just two or three. A key factor for Molloie is that the overall number of VC deals in San Diego has not declined precipitously, even though the amount of venture dollars invested has.
Molloie recently sent me a chart that shows the number of venture deals that PwC counted in the San Diego region has been climbing from 401 in 2003 to a peak of 638 in 2007. The number of deals declined to 561 in 2008, but Molloie said that’s not bad compared to 2006 (474 deals) 2005 (460 deals) and 2004 (460 deals).
Molloie’s chart also shows the number of active VCs headquartered in San Diego has not changed much. PwC’s tally shows there were 13 in 2003; 15 in 2004; 14 in 2005; 13 in 2006; 9 in 2007; and 14 in 2008. The chart also notes that four out-of-town venture capital firms have maintained offices in San Diego since 2003: Domain Associates, Sanderling Ventures, ProQuest Investments, and Sofinnova Ventures.
The big revelation for me is that the number of VCs that maintain a presence in San Diego is just a fraction of the number of out-of-town venture capital firms that are doing deals here.
In 2008, PwC found that 239 out-of-town VCs were involved in 490 deals that resulted in more than $1.24 billion in venture investments in the San Diego region. In contrast, the 14 VCs with San Diego headquarters were involved in 37 deals that resulted in almost $49.3 million in venture investments last year.
So it may be that we’re both right. Some of San Diego’s venerable homegrown VCs may no longer be investing, but the overall deal count for San Diego has remained relatively stable. Last year, 93 percent of the VCs doing business in San Diego were from out of town; they accounted for 87 percent of the 561 deals and 87 percent of the nearly $1.43 billion that was invested in San Diego technology startups.