From the Lab that Brought You Siri, It’s Trapit—A Personalized Discovery Engine

(Page 2 of 3)

they’re really just bringing together stories that have been flagged by the people you follow on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, or Google+. The information is only “personalized” in the sense that no one else has the same group of friends as you.

“This whole idea of using your social networks to find information is not really a solution, it’s an accommodation,” Gary Griffiths, Trapit’s CEO, argued to me recently. “It’s a recognition that there is way more stuff out there than you can ever find, so you just say, ‘I’m going to let my friends find it for me.'”

But what if your friends don’t share all of your interests, or aren’t very good at ferreting out the kinds of obscure news tidbits that might make your day, or are just dull people? The view at TrapIt is that the Web is a lot wider and deeper than either you or your friends can cope with—so wide and deep, in fact, that only software can be trusted to uncover the buried content that would be gold to you but dross to someone else. Hank Notthaft, Jr., chief product officer at Trapit, calls it “a discovery engine built for a Web that has grown so large and dynamic that it demands true personalization…While other platforms, from Google to Facebook and Twitter, are limited to what’s popular or what your so-called friends think is important, Trapit delivers what’s important to you.”

Like Siri, Trapit is an offshoot of the five-year, $200 million CALO research project. The goal of the project, which was based at SRI International in Menlo Park, CA and funded by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), was audacious: to create “systems that can reason, learn from experience, be told what to do, explain what they are doing, reflect on their experience, and respond robustly to surprise,” in the words of an SRI website.

Siri, which was spun off by SRI as a separate company in 2008 and acquired by Apple in April 2010, represents just one embodiment of that vision. The smartphone app is very good at parsing your spoken requests and assembling answers using the resources and data at hand, such as your contact list, calendar appointments, and current location.

Trapit is a very different embodiment. Its roots are in a program called CALO News Assistant, a prototype system built to help military personnel sift through news articles and blog posts. Users could select topics based on their fields, skills, or assignments and receive related article summaries via e-mail. “CALO learns the kind of articles you read and will highlight articles that best match your interests, focusing your attention on the most important articles,” in the words of one SRI brochure describing the system.

Nothhaft, who had worked as a product manager at WebEx and as a product marketing executive at business-telecom startup LiteScape Technologies, joined SRI in 2009 as an entrepreneur-in-residence, originally with the goal of sniffing out business collaboration and meeting technologies that might be ready for commercialization. He didn’t find anything that was ripe in those areas, but he did learn about CALO News Assistant. Nothhaft says he became “very excited…I’m an analyst by nature, and I’ve always been an information hound, with 2,000 feeds in my RSS reader.”

He thought that if the news assistant could be adapted for mainstream news consumers, it would be a powerful alternative to existing aggregation systems like that RSS reader. But there were two big problems: the news assistant scoured a limited selection of sources, and … Next Page »

Wade Roush is a contributing editor at Xconomy. Follow @wroush

Single Page Currently on Page: 1 2 3 previous page

Trending on Xconomy

By posting a comment, you agree to our terms and conditions.

  • Pingback: From the Lab that Brought You Siri, It’s Trapit—A Personalized Discovery Engine()

  • Pingback: From the Lab that Brought You Siri, It’s Trapit—A Personalized Discovery Engine | Siri iPhone4s()

  • http://www.dailygrommet.com Jules Pieri

    Wade…I love this line you wrote: “But what if your friends don’t share all of your interests, or aren’t very good at ferreting out the kinds of obscure news tidbits that might make your day, or are just dull people?” As you observe, news discovery is still not much advanced from the state of Amazon recommendations. A good start but blunt.

    Trapit sounds interesting. IF they can make their UX as fluid as Pinterest, and combine the easy teachability of Pandora, I’ll be a user. I’m not as patient as you to hack through new services. It’s great you do it for the rest of us!

  • http://www.davidparry.com David Parry

    I am wondering why is this old technology so interesting is it because Apple is just catching up? It sounds to me that the only reason why everyone thinks Apple is so revolutionary is because the media disregards are pays little attention until Apple does it. I have been using Android with voice on my phone for quite sometime with no problems and it does all of that and more since it now can control other devices so yes it can turn on the waffle maker.

  • Pingback: As I See It » Blog Archive » If you haven't got an iPhone 4S and Siri then Trapit()

  • Pingback: Reshared post from Jack Schofield – ..::Techstructable.com::..()

  • http://apps.evri.com Will Hunsinger

    Wade,
    Nice piece on Trap.it – i have been following these guys since private beta as much of what they are doing mimics what we launched on Evri.com back in 2009 like surfacing trending stories and topics from tens of thousands of sources, allowing users to follow the topics they love, bringing new stories to them. At Evri, we made a conscious decision to go Tablet and Mobile b/c, as you point out, that’s where folks really lean back and discover, browse news. You should check out Evri for iPad, I would welcome your thoughts.
    -Will Hunsinger
    CEO, Evri

  • Alan Bourke

    “it has brought state-of-the-art artificial intelligence technology”

    Puh-leeze.

  • Pingback: Iris (Siri for Android) released | KurzweilAI()

  • http://larkforsure.wordpress.com larkforsure

    [ SOS ] Complaint about Human Rights Violations by IBM China on Centennial

    Please Google:

    Tragedy of Labor Rights Repression in IBM China
    or
    How Much IBM Can Get Away with is the Responsibility of the Media
    or
    IBM detained mother of ex-employee on the day of centennials

  • Pingback: AI: Siri, next Trapit? « Tales from a Trading Desk()

  • Jules Pieri

    @David…I take your point but that is the idea behind building a trusted brand like Apple. You get huge unfair advantages for doing that hard spadework like Apple did…credit for translating technologies that you did not invent.

    I will say I had four Droids, I used the speech recognition feature, and was pretty fluent on the phone. But I recently switched to the iPhone because the UX of the Droid was just not as good and I was sick of bending my mind around a Droid developer’s biases rather than having a simple and intuitive approach. With Trapit I see the potential for the same “win”. I am not yet a user so I have to really try it to be definitive, but my initial impression is that they might be serving up this customized news service with a UX that complements the technology, rather than follows it. That is exactly what Apple did repeatedly.

  • http://thetechnologycafe.com Samir

    I would basically call it a mixture of Stumble Upon + Twitter plus a bit of AI
    The UI needs drastic improvements to make it more user friendly
    but great tool indeed
    http://thetechnologycafe.com/trap-itsocial-discovery-engine-aistumbleupontwitter-launches-review-pictures/#.TsItEfQUqdA

  • Pingback: In Kuato’s Game World, Knowledge is Power, and the AIs are Friendly | Xconomy()

  • Pingback: News, Social Networking Meet in Prismatic’s “Interest Network” | Xconomy()

  • Pingback: News, Social Networking Meet in Prismatic’s “Interest Network” | My Website()

  • Pingback: Putting choice into personalization | Story Needle()